Strongman Recap

Typically I don’t like to have too long of a recap for powerlifting and weightlifting meets, but strongman isn’t something I get a lot of recaps on (Paul, I will put yours up soon!). Antigen and ThunderThighs are my pals, and both train together and enjoy competing. Saul’s training and zest for competition reminds me of Gant (and that is high praise). In addition to lifting Antigen is almost nerdy and TT has a vibrant personality — I like these two. Antigen did a full meet recap, and I found it very interesting throughout. Additionally, there are a lot of vids, and I’ve embedded a few. See Antigen’s YouTube Channel for more. The rest is written by Saul.
–Justin


We competed in our first strongman Saturday April 30. I’m glad I did it but I wouldn’t do it again. (I’ll get to that later) ThunderThighs wants to do one again. It was hosted by a local gym a couple miles from where we live. I mentioned when I was signing up my girlfriend wished she could enter. The next time I was there they told me they’d create a women’s division for her. She was very excited when I brought the news home.

To train we lifted at our regular gym 4 days a week with squats, presses, o-lifts and deadlifts, the usual. We were allowed to train at Los Campeones after paying the entry fee as we had no where else to use the implements. We are really glad they were super super nice to let us do that. The gym owner (Benjamin Loehrer) is pretty cute, TT has a raging crush.

The meet was supposed to be held outside but it was pouring rain the day of so everything was inside. We got soaked on the bike ride there but had extra changes of clothes. Speaking of clothes I wore 3 shirts to minimize the pinching in the Axle continental clean & press, TT wore a tank top (single ply). Soaking wet, I still managed to weigh in as a light weight (<200lbs) but I didn't see my weight. ThunderThighs declined a weigh-in. A friend Tim whom I talked into entering his first meet with an entry fee (by cornering him at work) was MIA that morning. I will continue to bother him until he competes.

Event 1: Axle Clean and Press

[spoiler] The axle is a thick (2.25″) 100lb bar with non revolving sleeves. This makes Olympic clean techniques less useful at heavy weights.

ThunderThighs went first and although she was told it would be the empty bar for max reps, they changed it into max weight. She made 100,110,120 and missed 130’s jerk with no prior practice with continental technique. She was the only female lifting.

The Lightweight men started with 150 on the axle and made 20lb jumps. It was performed last man standing style and competitors had to lift every weight on the way up. I power cleaned and pressed my first 3 attempts but switched to a continental clean and split jerk style so I would be ready for heavy at 210 and up. Some of the 6 lightweights were already eliminated by that point because they were weak and/or didn’t know how to Jerk. The third place lifter was knocked out by 250. I lifted 270 easily but was dreading the pain olympics of continental cleaning even heavier weights. Fortunately the other lifter who had magnetic hands and was power cleaning all his attempts missed at 270 and was knocked out. The 5 heavyweight men started with 200, made 20lb jumps and two lifters failed to get 280, a weight I had continental cleaned in training. It’s disappointing to leave bigger lifts in the tank but there was no incentive for lifts beyond 1st place and continentals damage skin even with 3 shirts.

Antigen’s legit 270 lbs axle clean and press:


TT 120 lbs
[/spoiler]

Event 2: Atlas Stones for Height

[spoiler]The goal was to lift over the axle placed between some squat stands which were raised after each attempt. At maximum extension, the bar was high enough for me to walk under it, I’m 5’7″.

Thunderthighs was never able to lift their lightest atlas stone, 135lb, higher than a few inches off the floor in training. Her substitute was an 85lb sandbag, she was tossing it higher than neck height before she failed.

This event took forever. I had suggested the lightweights use the 235lb stone, but because there were some younger and weaker lifters 190lbs was the starting weight. 3 lifters including myself were able to launch the ball over the 6′ goal after 10+ rounds of lower heights. The tie break was to use the 235lb stone, which continued for several more increases until the tallest guy who also was strong enough to shoulder it won. (Big surprise) I tied for second with a lift around eye height. The heavyweights were able to lift to the same notch as us but started with 235.

I trained for this event improperly because I assumed a heavy stone like 235 or 265 was going to be used so it wouldn’t become a how tall are you contest. So I practiced only with those and even got 265 chest high my third practice session.

[/spoiler]

Event 3: Deadlift Medley

[spoiler]4 Deadlift stations for time.

TT had a 200lb olympic bar, 100lb DBs, 225 hex bar and 240 axle. She made 240 look easy but it was a 5lb pr for any type of bar.


Mens lightweight had 365 olympic, 200lb suitcases, 425 hex and 455 axle. I got 455 to knee height with very little rest, it was a disappointing miss as I hit 475 two weeks ago in the TSC. I disagreed with the scoring of this event as people who attempted the 4th bar but couldn’t lift clocked a worse time than those who simply quit after station 3. 3 people got it, 2 missed it and 1 didn’t try.

Heavyweights had about 500lbs on the hex and olympic bars, 250lb suitcases, and 530 on the axle which no one was able to successfully lift.


[/spoiler]

Event 4: Sandbag Clean and Press for max reps in 90s

[spoiler]This was another event that was switched on us, it was supposed to be Circus Dumbbell Clean and Press for max reps in 90s. The lightweight division was to use the lighter of their two circus DBs but I preferred lifting with the 130lb dumbbell as it was a little more compact and was heavier and had done doubles with it. Then some idiot broke the lighter circus dumbbell the week before the contest so everything was switched to sandbags 85, 120 and 150 for the three divisions.

TT got the bag over her head a couple times but was unable to get a complete lift. The extra upper body involvement controlling the sandbag made 70% not a very good female scale, further hers was the most unstable as it was the least full.

The only sandbag there was to practice with leading up to this event was 85# and it was so light I never touched it again. I had trouble with the rules of this event. First touch and go was not allowed, which I did accidentally once, then another rep that I had actually let go of was wrongly DQ’d. So just a few seconds in I was pissed and two reps behind, so I tried to go as fast as possible by not resetting at my chest. On one “press” (mine were more like snatches) I twisted my left shoulder funny, it hurt pretty bad so I hope I’m not injured. Several more of my reps weren’t counted because it was drooping too much in front of my face and the rule was get your head under at lockout. I rage quit with 10 seconds still on the clock I was so disgusted with the event (Editor’s Note: gg). The top 3 tied at 14 reps. I had 8 which counted and almost as many attempts that did not count.

The best reps for the 150lb heavyweight division sandbag was 6.
[/spoiler]

Event 5: Farmers Walk, Tire Flip and Keg Carry Race

[spoiler]TT used 225 on the trap bar, which is a really impressive load to walk with, being just 20lbs below her new 1rm. She used her best friend (the 85# sandbag) in place of a keg.

Lightweights used the 200lb suitcases. Everyone was tripping on the rubber floor mats while carrying the Keg, including me. I placed second in this event with 40.5s, third place was 41s. The guy who got first did it in 30.0, I’d recommend watching me and then imagine what 35% faster would look like. We’re talking Brent Kim proportions of Dianabol to be able to sprint carrying 400 pounds of weight.

Heavyweights had a 495lb trap bar to walk with and a heavier keg. Everyone that wore a belt found the Keg pretty unwieldy because it would pivot against the buckle I would highly recommend not using one. No one had to set the farmers walk implements down including a 165lb 16 year old. The only people to not actually trip at some point were TT and the lightweight winner.

Editor’s Note: After watching this vid, Brent said, “Antigen’s kind of a maniac.”

[/spoiler]

Event 6: Truck Pull

[spoiler] TT’s sub was pushing the owner’s Mini Cooper the same distance the men pulled the truck. This was her first time ever pushing a car, which is really surprising for living in Minnesota.

Grip was a big issue here, we wore rubber gloves but I’m not sure how much it helped. My strategy was to use two arms to get it rolling and then go for speed with one handed pulls but I lost a lot of power from slipping. It turned out using a two handed pull was the best for the conditions. It felt very anticlimactic finishing with an event where you couldn’t tell who was faster or slower from watching and no one was able to pull their hardest.

[/spoiler]


Overall I placed third, the tall dude second and the dianabol dude first. For this I won 1 month of gym membership to Los Campeones.

I wouldn’t do another competition because I don’t feel that strongman as well refined a sport as Powerlifting or Weightlifting (or even the TSC). Many of the events did not challenge the limit strength or power of any of the competitors, including Keg carry, tire flipping, and sandbag presses. If strongman is the title the implements shouldn’t be light enough that everyone who enters can lift them! Since I did not know the weights and distances ahead of time and some of the events were changed on us it wouldn’t meet Justin’s definition of sport either. http://www.70sbig.com/blog/2011/04/sport/ The scoring of the deadlift medley, especially for the heavyweights introduced substantial random noise into the scoring. For them the winner was the person who took the least time to realize he couldn’t lift the 530 axle not who completed the first 3 lifts fastest. Finishing place in stones for height was like sorting us by height after accounting for physical ability to lift the 235. In events where lifters tied for the same place they could have broke the tie by bumping the lighter lifter ahead but they had ties stand. But I don’t like the sum of placings scoring in general because it does not reward any effort beyond what gets 1st and can make the least bad athlete win instead of the strongest overall.

Despite that I’d still recommend trying a strongman contest if you are an intermediate with competitive experience and want to shake up your training. It’s probably more fun than a Crossfit competition and if you’re the strongest you just might win. If you’ve never competed: a powerlifting or weightlifting meet is a safer bet because you’ll be able to practice all the lifts of the competition and know the rules ahead of time.

23 thoughts on “Strongman Recap

  1. Congrats on your first strongman competition. If it was better run and kept consistent, would you be interested in trying it again?

  2. Note: Professional and/or amateur strongman federations have set rules on what is allowed or not in competition. This particular competition sounded local and didn’t maintain any sanctioned rules (I assume). Had it been sanctioned, it probably would have removed some of Antigen’s irritation at changing events, scoring, and placing. But I don’t know, I am speculating.

  3. The drawback with the strongman federations is that they have pretty hefty membership fees, in addition to hefty entry fees. I do not know how it compares to powerlifting or oly federations but its hella more than highland games. Since events also usually require travel, it can get pretty expensive pretty fast.

    Local games have the benefit of being cheap by comparison but also tend to be short on official equipment, changing events etc.

  4. Saul, this sounds like a horribly run event. The first video alone was proof as any well run show doesn not allow resting the bar on your belt during a clean. Also, changing of events is pretty poor form, as well as the terrible way the scored the deadlift medley. If you’re willing to pay the membership fee (I believe it is $40 for NAS) and the entry fees to their sanctioned contest (usually $50-60) I would definitely suggest trying another one. You can use the Marunde Muscle forum as a resource as well to find quality shows.

  5. I have to agree with Paul Sousa here. A properly run strongman event will list all events, with details on implements, rules, scoring ahead of time. I’ve participated in 2 NAS events and they’ve been much better organized than the event written up here.

    I don’t find the cost to be more prohibitive then powerlifting, and there can be the bonus of prize money.

    lastly, most strongman events will not require limit strength, but being stronger always helps in all events

  6. I assume there will be a chat tonight? I have some questions.

    No chat tonight, folks. Finishing a project, so we’ll do it tomorrow.

    –Justin

  7. The events were posted on the wall at the gym and on their website (it was still up as of yesterday). But circus DB was switched out and truck pull moved to be last in hopes the rain would stop.

    I knew it was illegal to set the axle on the belt in a normal competition but I asked the gym owner twice about it and both times got “yes it’s what I do.”

    To be fair to the gym, I would assume they would improve this with subsequent competitions (at least the scoring part). That kind of stuff can be difficult to plan around if you are inexperienced, but I don’t know if they had experience or not.

    –Justin

  8. As Justin said, I would assume (hope) this gym hasn’t put on many shows before this one. But honestly I think you could do very well in your weight class if you were to try another show. As it sounds like you are a very competitive person I think you should try and find a well run show in your area before you write off strongman altogether.

  9. Excellent write-up. Antigen is a beast, and it looks like he’s walking around on tree trunks from that sandbag clean and press video.

  10. That guy who is obviously blind (Sandbag Lift Judge) would have gotten yelled at if I was there. You let go every time and he told you to drop it. WTF? The next time he said you gotta let go I would have been 75% done with a round-house kick aimed at him when he said it.

  11. This was their second strongman competition.

    Their first one was held in Fall 2010. Last one had Log Press for reps in 90s, Stones for max Weight, 400lb axle deadlift for max reps in 90s, a similar tire flip & keg carry medley, farmers walk for max distance without dropping and I think a truck pull.

    Here’s someone I beat named Eddie Lone Eagle:

  12. Not sure if this is anywhere near you, but it’s in MN. If you’re looking for a better challenge in terms of strength this looks like it would be a good choice. It also looks like it’s open in terms of weight class so you’d be going up against some huge dudes, but you coudl see how you stack up against them. And apparently Dave Ostlund will be competing so it must be pretty legit. It also has cash prizes. I don’t think it’s an NAS event either so you’d only have the entry fee.

    http://www.strengthauthority.com/2011%20Rochester's%20Strongest%20Man%20entry%20form.pdf

  13. The guy who won my weight division said he was gonna enter that. I like the events, Clean and Press reps on a regular barbell with weight choice is sweet. I could get a rep or two on 315. I like the open weight class part too, I don’t like weight divisions.

    But I’ve competed in powerlifting in the middle of February, the TSC, an all day Starcraft 2 tournament and then this Strongman in April. So I just want a break and I will lose my access to stones after I graduate and move out of Minneapolis.

  14. “Saul, this sounds like a horribly run event. The first video alone was proof as any well run show doesn not allow resting the bar on your belt during a clean.”

    This is not true. Some lightweight shows allow this because the competitors do not have anything else to rest this on. It really isn’t significant at all, so long as the rule is applied to everyone.

    I agree it sounds badly run though. A well run SM competition is much more fun than powerlifting for anyone sane.

  15. I run Rochester’s Strongest Man and found that you mentioned it on the internet. I think its a fun contest for the lightweight amateur all the way to the big time pro (like a Dave Ostlund). We try to have events that everyone competing can have some success with while keeping it competitive as possible. Last year it was on a day with good weather, and we had a good turn out for spectators and athletes alike. If you’d like more information shoot me an email or visit strengthauthority.com

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.